Call ’em Out Or Call ’em Off ! The NCAA Continues To Be Just One Big Joke !

Call ’em Out Or Call ’em Off ! The NCAA Continues To Be Just One Big Joke !

I was always under the impression that one of the primary reasons and purposes of the NCAA was to oversee collegiate athletics. And also to be of benefit to the student athletes and to safeguard their interests and to make that sports at the collegiate available to all scholastic eligible student athlete. Somehow one equation that the NCAA is now hiding behind and not making available whole to the public is that of the graduation rates of the athletes in a number of programs, the different sports and from specific educational establishments. But yet the NCAA is able to avail itself indirect public funding from the federal government as well as its exempt status courtesy of the US Congress and Senate . Unfortunately what the NCAA’s mission statement sets out and what it practices are two different things completely !

Ed (13), a senior power forward, and brother Charles (31), a sophomore small forward, comprised two-fifths of the starting lineup for the UCLA team which won the 1995 NCAA men\’s basketball tournament. Known for their trademark shaved heads and explosive style of play, the O\’Bannon brothers have been credited with returning UCLA basketball to national relevance during the mid-\’90s. photo appears courtesy of Reuters / Dick Baldwin ……………

The entity itself is conducted as a private corporate enterprise but maintains its tax exempt status as a charitable organization. At the same time many of its perverse practices denies the student athlete the chance to actually part-take of earning a living in order to cover their costs while undertaking their education. But at the same time the NCAA itself and the educational establishments themselves are allowed to make tens of millions of dollars by using the likeness of the athletes in order to benefit themselves as an organization. We’re told that this is all done to benefit the student athlete . But in reality is there any tangible evidence to show that this is the case ?

Courtesy of Associated Press & ESPN

Suit over likenesses gains more names

San Francisco — Former college basketball players spanning many eras have joined a lawsuit filed by ex-UCLA star Ed O’Bannon against the NCAA for profiting from the use of their images without permission.

In an amended complaint filed in U.S. District Court on Wednesday, four players involved in the 1966 national championship game that pitted a Texas Western team with five black starters against an all-white Kentucky team joined in the suit.

Those players include Harry Flournoy, who was team captain for Texas Western, which is now UTEP, which beat the 1966 Kentucky squad in a game now seen as a driving force in the integration of college sports. The game was also documented in the 2006 movie “Glory Road.”

Texas Western teammate David Lattin and 1966 Kentucky players Thad Jaracz and Bob Tallent also joined the suit as plaintiffs.

The lawsuit states “during broadcasts of the yearly NCAA tournament, the NCAA has run commercials … featuring the Texas Western team. The NCAA also prominently features the 1966 Texas Western team … in connection with products for sale.”

NCAA spokesman Erik Christianson says the allegations are false and that the NCAA does not license student-athlete likenesses or prevent former players from attempting to do so.

“The plaintiffs’ claim that the NCAA violates antitrust laws because it somehow prevents former student-athletes from capitalizing on their collegiate images or likenesses is fiction,” Christianson said in an e-mail.

The lawsuit also alleges video game maker Electronic Arts Inc., and NCAA partner Collegiate Licensing Co. also unlawfully profited from player images without compensating the athletes.

Players from other famous games and teams who also joined the suit include Alex Gilbert, who played on the same Indiana State team as Larry Bird in the notable 1979 championship game won by Earvin “Magic” Johnson’s Michigan State squad.

Eric Riley, a member of the University of Michigan’s “Fab Five” teams in the early 1990s is also a plaintiff in the suit, as are a number of former college football players including ex-University of Nebraska and Arizona State University quarterback Samuel Keller.


Currently within the US Federal Court System there’s a lawsuit that has been filed by ex UCLA Bruins’ basketball player Ed O’Bannon . He has since been joined by a number of ex NCAA athletes that’ve jointly signed unto the suit challenging the NCAA’s use of their likeness. The premise behind the lawsuit is that the NCAA violates antitrust laws that prevents the student athlete from capitalizing on the use of their likeness. Also joint defendants in the case are Electronic Arts Inc and Collegiate Licensing Co (the licensing arm of the NCAA ). There are those who view this as a way to make the NCAA transparent as to many of its dealings pertaining to the student athletes and the monies derived from their using of their image. There’s no denying that over the years the NCAA has derived billions of dollars by the use of the student athlete’s image. And one might make the claim that the NCAA has been judicious in using revenue to the benefit of collegiate athletics. But there’s no way to truly know how much of that money is actually reinvested into college sports and how much of it actually finds its way into the pockets of the board and faculty members around collegiate academia . If as such as is the case where the monies are being used for the benefit of collegiate sports and that of the various collegiate establishments and their programs. Then let the NCAA be completely transparent by opening up its books for public scrutiny.

Instead a great deal of the time the NCAA would rather punish with impunity any athlete who violates their rules . Even if it is any many cases just a minor transgression. If an athlete should be deemed as having some financial benefit from having worked off campus and has earned a salary. They are viewed as having violated on the NCAA’s most stringent and draconian rules. But never let it be said that the NCAA can’t go out and use the likeness of athletes such as Tim Tebow, Sam Bradford , Colt McCoy , Evan Turner , John Wall , Trevon Hughes , Sherron Collins , Maya Moore or Tina Charles for their own benefit. The NCAA would have you believe that what they’re doing is completely above board. And they’d be right if it wasn’t for the fact that this borders on being tantamount to enslavement. There are those who’d say that the reciprocal benefit to the athlete is an education. But that doesn’t equate with how the NCAA conducts itself and how it enacts its bye laws. They profit financially from using a student athlete’s likeness. But if that athlete were to go into business for themselves while still in school and use their likeness as a commercial enterprise as it relates to their sport . Then they’d run afoul of NCAA rules. How asinine is that to begin with ?

Education Secretary   Arne  Duncan  seen  here  alongside   President  Barack  Obama,  having  just publicly   accepted   being  nominated  for the   position  .   photo  appears  courtesy  of  Associated  Press/  Rick    Fuller  ..............
Education Secretary Arne Duncan seen here alongside President Barack Obama, having just publicly accepted being nominated for the position . photo appears courtesy of Associated Press/ Rick Fuller ..............

Education Secretary Arne Duncan , a keen basketball fan, much like President Barack Obama , has some very interesting opinions and observations concerning the participants in the NCAA Men’s Basketball Tournament and how they’re made eligible for competition. His views make a great deal of sense but would run counter to how the conferences set about the qualifying standards for their respective schools. Conferences tournaments through knockout competition and then an empaneled group gets together to discuss the merits of the 34 at large bids that are then offered to make up the field of sixty five, with a play in game for the final entrant’s bid. Seems equitable enough doesn’t it ? However, what Education Secretary Arne Duncan would like to see is the participants entered based on graduation rates. As to how that would fly not only with the NCAA , the schools and conferences . Well , I’ll let you be the judge of that .

Arne  Duncan

Education Secretary Arne Duncan seen here addressing the convened press having just formally accepted the position as the nation\’s highest education officer. photo appears courtesy of Associated Press/ Travis Rourke …….

Courtesy of USA Today

Education Secretary Duncan: Ban NCAA teams with low grad rates

By Erik Brady , USA Today

Washington , D.C. — If U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan had his way, a dozen of the teams in the men’s NCAA basketball tournament would not be eligible to play in it, including top-seeded Kentucky.

Duncan proposes teams with graduation rates of less than 40% be banned from postseason play.

WHAT IF:What if NCAA brackets were based on best in class, not on court?
ARNE DUNCAN: Basketball provided a life assist for education secretary
DUNCAN ON COLLINS: Education secretary fan of Kansas guard

“That’s a low bar,” Duncan said Tuesday. “If you can’t graduate two out of five of your student-athletes, how serious are you about the academic part of your mission?”

The schools that have men’s basketball teams with graduation rates of less than 40% are Arkansas-Pine Bluff (29%), Baylor (36%), California (20%), Clemson (37%), Georgia Tech (38%), Kentucky (31%), Louisville (38%), Maryland (8%), Missouri (36%), New Mexico State (36%), Tennessee (30%) and Washington (29%).

Those figures come from NCAA rates compiled by The Institute for Diversity and Ethics in Sport at Central Florida. They do not include transfers or players who leave early for the NBA. They do not reflect athletes who will play in the tourney, as they include the most recent four-year classes that have had six years to graduate.

Duncan will participate in a teleconference today with the study’s primary author, Richard Lapchick.

The Department of Education cannot impose a 40% solution on NCAA schools, but Duncan said he would use his office to advocate for reform.

“Why do we tolerate the bad apples … when the vast majority are doing things well?” he said. “Everybody sees it. It’s out in the open. … And somehow things don’t change.”

Click the headlined link to read this article in its entirety

Though the Department of Education doesn’t have the power to enforce a rule concerning the competition and how the NCAA accepts the entrants for the men’s and women’s tournament. The very thought that such a proposal could be elicited and gain a wide view of acceptance where a 40 % minimum graduation rate would be deemed as the entrance level for the NCCA tournament would probably send shivers up down the spines of the coaches and athletics directors up and down the country. I’d dare say that it’d force the academic advisers and compliance officers and their subordinates to actually do their jobs more judiciously , with more veracity and most certainly with a great deal more transparency than we’re led to believe that now takes place. Can you imagine what that would actually force John Calipari to do ? Better yet don’t think about it because that was the same thing that led to both Memphis and U Mass to have sanctions enforced upon them by the NCAA. But yet Calipari , himself , was untouched by the scandal , even though he was the central figure in both cases.

It certainly makes you wonder if the cat was set amongst the pigeons how many schools would actually meet the criteria if entrance to the national championship events such as collegiate football, basketball, baseball , lacrosse , track & field and even soccer were to adopt such a policy where entrance were based upon the graduation level within the athletics’ programs and that level were at a base of 40 %. Does anyone think that a number of the entrants at both the mens and womens at this year’s national championships would actually meet that criteria ? It’s bad enough that some of the entrants at this year’s men’s tournament even fail that proposed minimum level. Schools such as Louisville , Baylor , Clemson , Maryland , Tennessee and Washington would all fail to meet that minimum entrance level. It makes you wonder what the kids are learning and why it is that there’s nothing at all being done by the NCAA to actual monitor athletic program’s graduation rate levels more judiciously.

With the NCAA still without a sitting President to preside over the body , after the death of Myles Brand . It is now essentially devoid of leadership while their search committee looks for a new leader to take over as President. Though for now , James L Isch is the Interim-President . Makes one wonder who does look after the hen-house while the rooster is away ? The more one takes to viewing the NCAA seriously, is actually the more you tend to view it as a particularly corrupt but yet extremely powerful organization. It even has member of both Federal legislative houses at its beck and call to do its bidding. That’s power that is extremely corrupt , most definitely dangerous. But yet they’re entrusted to oversee collegiate athletics. There’s something drastically wrong with this picture. And not even the US Congress or Senate is prepared to do a damn thing about it. I wonder why ? Could it be that they’re far to scared to upset the ‘gravy train’ that comes their way by way of assistance, courtesy of the NCAA ? Every sporting body has its lobbyists up on K Street. But perhaps , none is as powerful as the lobbyists that are in the employ of the NCAA. Just simply look out for the supporters of the body and you can very well see the power that they derive within Washington, D.C.

Alan Parkins aka tophatal …………………..


50 cent ……… ‘I Get Money’ This may well be the ‘one song’ that completely embodies what the NCAA is actually all about ! .


Author: tophatal ...........

An avid sports' fans that's all !!!!!

9 thoughts on “Call ’em Out Or Call ’em Off ! The NCAA Continues To Be Just One Big Joke !”

  1. Good points. Finally some one is listening to me. The NCAA uses these kids to make mega bucks. Follow the money. Where does all the money go. Whose pocket does this money end in? The kids are used. Most of these kids don’t want to be in college. They are their to improve their hoops skills. Check out UNM when Dave Bliss was headman. Ike Williams, Khari Jaxon, Luc Longley et all. Trust me on this.
    Education is a scam.
    Graduation rates are bogus. This is meaningless. 90% of these kids have visions of the NBA dancing in their head. Do like MLB. Pay the kids and have them play in farm system.
    Be real. It is all about the money. Nothing more read Dave Meggassey’s book Meat on the Hoof.


    1. Bobby Gee

      I’ve long maintained the view that the NCAA is a corrupt criminal enterprise ! Were it a Colombian or Mexican drug cartel then both the FBI and Justice Dept would be on them like flies around a pile of cow sh_t ! But no neither they or the Congress or Senate does a damn thing. Either they’re too scared or they just pay it all lip service when it comes to talking about a playoff system for college football at the Division 1 level.

      Education has always been a scam as it relates to the student athlete. There are times where’s the exception the rule. But more often than not that’s a rarity. I mean you had idiots questioning the fact that FSU’s Myron Rolle didn’t want to pursue a career in the NFL because he’d been accepted to Oxford as a Rhodes’ scholar. The fact that the kid wants to study to become a neuro-surgeon just didn’t seem to matter to those as_holes as they thought he’d be better off in the NFL. Avg career in the NFL for a offensive or defensive player , no more than 6-8 years at best. Career for a neuro-surgeon ? I’d say thirty or so years , given their determination and skillset ! Not much of a choice is it ? Earning power may well be less but the acclaim of becoming a world class neuro-surgeon far outweighs those disadvantages.

      Alan Parkins


  2. Nice post Al! I couldn’t agree more that a great majority of kids aren’t there to get an education. It’s a shame that they are taken advantage of in pretty much every way, but at the same time they are just trying to boost thier stocks for the NBA draft, so in essence they are using the schools somewhat too. One thing I like is how some kids like Brandon Jennings are heading overseas instead of going to college for a one and done, since all he really did was get a few bucks while learning the game better. I really like how he got overseas experience too…


    1. chappy 81

      MLB pays the kids upon entrance into the farm system of major league organization. That’s about the only positive thing I can really say about Selig and the hierarchy . Everything else to me is a mute point as far as baseball is concerned and how they conduct their business !

      See my comments to Bobby Gee with regard to FSU’s Myron Rolle as evidence as to what I feel is exemplary and the idiotic stupidity of some of the tv pundits within Foxsports , ABC/ESPN .

      They’re critical of a guy who has to choose between accepting a position at Oxford and perhaps the most prestigious award in collegiate education, a Rhodes’ scholarship . Wherein Rolle will study in the UK while pursuing his degree in medicine and then choosing to become a neuro-surgeon. WTF is wrong with these a-holes on tv ?

      Alan Parkins


    2. chappy 81

      Don’t get me wrong there’s nothing like traveling to broaden one’s horizons and to gain experience. But in all honesty Jennings only did that to circumvent the league’s rules and that’s it. And in doing so he got rewarded handsomely. But let’s say he suffers a career ending injury what does he then have to fall back on terms of his employment prospect ? He has no real education other than a ‘GED’ and that’s it.

      Can you see Jennings wanting to flip burgers at McDonald’s should that scenario arise ?

      Alan Parkins


  3. Great post Al. I have conflicting feelings on this issue. Yes, the NCAA is taking advantage of these kids, but these same kids have an opportunity to obtain a college degree, something that should not be taken lightly.
    There have been millions of people that have struggled mightily to send their chidren or themselves to college.
    Let the kids who want to be paid play in a minor league type situation and have the scholar athletes represent their respective schools.


    1. aero

      The thing is , the kids are a ‘big business’ for the NCAA and ‘why kill the golden goose’ or ‘fatted calf’ as far as they’re concerned ? And that’s what they’re being asked to do if they allow the kids a stipend . It’d cut into the money that they pass around the major conferences as well as put into their own damn pockets. You can’t justify the likes of Saban and Meyer making in excess of $4million a year , while a student athlete at times struggles to make ends meet. That’s an asinine notion to begin with.

      The NCAA under the interim President James L Isch had better get their heads out of the clouds. Because if they should wind up losing this federal case then all hell is going to break loose amongst the athletes as they look to get paid. And I’m not just talking about now but from the past as well. It could very well end up costing them tens of millions of dollars.

      This problem isn’t the fault of the kids but simply put , it’s the way that the rules of the NCAA have been constructed. It’s archaic and far too prohibitive !

      Alan Parkins


    1. Chris Humpherys

      Recently James L Isch the interim President of the NCAA made the statement that paying the student athlete would muddy the waters of what was meant to amateurism in collegiate athletics. WTF ? They make literally ‘billions’ of the backs of these kids and he’s talking about amateurism ?

      The NCAA for all sense and purpose is a very corrupt and exploitative enterprise that has been emboldened by the networks and both legislative houses of the government .

      Alan Parkins


Leave a Reply & notification by e-mail

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.