(2) (2) From left to right, Andy Pettite, Derek Jeter , Mariano Rivera and Jorge Posada . This quartet of players have been together some of New York Yankees ‘ biggest triumphs and disappointments over the past eighteen years . It now begs the question will the franchise ever see that type of success again with regard to number of titles won between 1996 and 2004 , with the last of the ball club’s triumphs coming in 2009 with Joe Girardi as the manager ? The four titles won together as teammates prior to Girardi becoming the manager were all achieved under Joe Torre , now an executive within the MLB hierarchy. Getty Images / Richard Moss ….